Yandere!Smiling Critters x Male!Reader
Y/n L/n was just a normal orphaned child but doesn't have many friends in his life and his only friends are the Smiling Critters gang made by Playtime Co, a family friendly toy company that made amazing toys li...
Inside of Y/n's dream, Y/n found himself in the old orphanage once again and in the lunchroom no less. Then he spotted a PB&J sandwich on a nearby table with a note that says: "I made this PB&J sandwich just for you - Love PiggyPicky"
Y/n: Huh...I didn't know that she made a PB&J sandwich just for me. PB&Js are her favorite snack. (Looks at the sandwich) Wait a second...something's not right.
Y/n took a closer look at the PB&J sandwich and the crusts on the bread are cut off, but the only difference is both the peanut butter and jelly that looks more like white cheese or mayonnaise or marshmallow fluff. Then when he took a sniff at the sandwich, it smelled exactly like Peanut Butter and Jelly, but he just doesn't understand why the Peanut Butter and Jelly looked all white like they lost their colors.
Y/n: Ehh....I think I'll pass on the PB&J...it looks so weird looking. I think it's gone bad or something. I better throw it out.
???: You're gonna throw that PB&J sandwich away that I made for you? I thought we were friends, Y/n.
Y/n: Huh?
He then turns around to see PickyPiggy look away from Y/n and facing the wall in front of her, but for some strange reason, her whole body is all grey instead of her natural pink color.
Y/n: PickyPiggy? How long have you been standing there?
PickyPiggy: Oh, not too long, just wanted to see you enjoy eating that PB&J Sandwich that I made for you, but now you're throwing it away, after all the good times we had together and eating and sharing our favorite snacks. How could you do that to me, Y/n?
Y/n: I-I'm sorry, PickyPiggy. I didn't know that you felt that way and you made this for me, but I just had a bad feeling about this PB&J because it looked like the peanut butter and jelly was expired or something. I'm sorry for hurting your feelings like that, PickyPiggy. We can always make more PB&J sandwiches together, if that's ok with you.
PickyPiggy: Oh, don't worry. I forgive you, Y/n, but you're still gonna eat that PB&J sandwich I made for you and if you're planning to throw it away... I'll just make you eat it!
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
Then PickyPiggy turned her head to look at Y/n as her eyes looked evil with a sharp toothy grin on her face that made Y/n's blood run cold.
Y/n: Oh my God! What the heck happen to you, PickyPiggy?! What happen to your color and why do you look so evil right now?!?
PickyPiggy: Oh, it's nothing, except I lost my color after you left us for over 10 years since you were adopted, and we lost our beautiful colors after that. But now that you came back to us, I think we're gonna celebrate your return after we make you....one of us!
Y/n: AYO WHAT?!
PickyPiggy then slowly stepped towards Y/n, but he decided to make a break for it through the exit doors to get away from her.
