I Want You Both- Remus Lupin x Reader x James Potter Marauders Threesome Smut

5.6K 31 3
                                    


All three of you sat in their dorm, they had been short with each other all month but now it broke out into a fight. "I asked her out first!" James was shouting, it wasn't very often he got so angry.

"Does not matter! I asked her out after the party the other night and she said yes, so maybe you're not as charming as you think you are," Remus scoffed. You watched them yell at each other and were starting to get fed up with them.

"We have sex!" James got up in Remus's face, Remus hated it when people got too close. Remus pushed James back forcefully but you could tell he didn't want to hurt him, but the full moon was approaching and he lacked his usual self-control.

"So do we!" Remus shouts as he makes a fist. You did not want them to fight over you, you liked them both so much and this was getting out of hand. Remus pulled his fist back ready to send it right at James's face.

"ENOUGH!" You stood up and put yourself between them. "I am sick of the bickering, what is wrong with you two?! You guys used to be so close and now you're doing all this because of me. Maybe the reason I have been seeing both of you is because I like both of you, a lot, and I can't choose," You sighed, looking between the two. "But if me seeing the both of you is going to do this to your friendship then it's over with you both, it's either I have you both or neither of you," you huffed and sat at the foot of James's bed. They sighed and looked at each other and then at you.

"What do you mean both of us?" James approached you and sat on one side of you. Your cheeks reddened at the thought of telling them what you've been wanting, to have them both on you, making you feel good. James sat there next to you a bit confused. He could not figure out if you meant you wanted to keep seeing them both or if you wanted to date them together. Remus on the other hand already knew what you wanted and let a small smirk play on the corner of his lips.

"Hands and knees," Remus growled, tilting his head towards the ground for you to get on it.

"W-What?" Your stomach did flips and you felt an ache between your thighs.

"Don't what me, I said hands and knees, this is what you wanted all along so we're going to give it to you, right Prongs?" Remus looked at him. James was dumbfounded but also turned on as you could tell from the growing bulge in his trousers.

"Er- Yeah," James looked at you, he felt a bit intimidated, not knowing exactly how this was going to play out but he definitely wanted to try it out, he was going to have you in any way he could. Your heart was pounding in your chest, and your panties quickly became soaked as you got onto your hands and knees in front of Remus.

"Good girl," Remus teased and looked at James, "Do you want her cunt or her mouth?" Your clit was throbbing from the thought and you waited for James to respond to Remus but you found that he was looking at you.

"Where do you want me, love?" James asked you. Pleasuring you was all that mattered to him, he didn't care where he finished as long as he got to make you shake.

"I want you two to take turns, I don't care who cums where but I want to have you both in my mouth and fucking me before either of you cum," you blushed. James's ears were pink and he nodded and got behind you. He ran his hands up and down your thighs and the curve of your ass before flicking your skirt up to your waist.

"So pretty," James mumbled as he pulled down your drenched panties, "So wet already are you, darling?" He teased as he took himself off his trousers and boxers and pressed his erection right up against your entrance letting his tip tease you. You whined at the feeling of having him so close, your walls clenched around nothing so needy for him to fill you up.

Harry Potter OneshotsWhere stories live. Discover now